New Users Registration  |  Useful Links  |  FAQ  |  Site Map 
Go Search


Skip Navigation LinksHealth Xchange > News
  2013 2015   Dec 2015 | Nov 2015 | Oct 2015 | Sep 2015 | Aug 2015 | Jul 2015 | Jun 2015 | May 2015 | Apr 2015 | Mar 2015 | Feb 2015 | Jan 2015 |
  2013 2014   Dec 2014 | Nov 2014 | Oct 2014 | Sep 2014 | Aug 2014 | Jul 2014 | Jun 2014 | May 2014 | Apr 2014 | Mar 2014 | Feb 2014 | Jan 2014 |
  2013   Dec 2013 | Nov 2013 | Oct 2013 | Sep 2013 | Aug 2013 | Jul 2013 | Jun 2013 | May 2013 | Apr 2013 | Mar 2013 | Feb 2013 | Jan 2013 |
  2012   Dec 2012 | Nov 2012 | Oct 2012 | Sep 2012 | Aug 2012 | Jul 2012Jun 2012May 2012Apr 2012Mar 2012 | Feb 2012 | Jan 2012 |
  2011   Dec 2011Nov 2011Oct 2011 | Sep 2011 | Aug 2011Jul 2011Jun 2011 | May 2011 | Apr 2011 | Mar 2011 | Feb 2011 | Jan 2011 |
  2010   Dec 2010 | Nov 2010 | Oct 2010 | Sep 2010 | Aug 2010 | Jul 2010 | Jun 2010 | May 2010 | Apr 2010 | Mar 2010 | Feb 2010 | Jan 2010 |
  2009   Dec 2009 | Nov 2009 | Oct 2009 | Sep 2009 | Aug 2009 |
  Health Policy and Announcements | Diseases and Outbreaks
  Medical Research | New Treatments and Technology
  Singapore   SingHealth | Health Promotion Board | Ministry of Health | Asiaone
  International   World Health Organization | Centre for Disease Control and Prevention (US)
  News Article  

Just one class of wards will do

  Saturday, 04 l 12 l 2010 Source:  The Straits Times   
By: Salma Khalik

With means testing, we don’t need many classes of subsidised wards  

subsidised-wardHEALTH-CARE standards evolve over time, and the latest example is in the C class ward of the new Khoo Teck Puat Hospital (KTPH) in Yishun. The traditional C class hospital ward has rows of beds lined up dormitory style in a long room, with toilets and shower areas along common corridors outside.

In contrast, the new C class ward, while housing 10 patients per room, groups five patients in an enclosed area with en suite toilet and shower facilities. The ward is laid out so each bed has a window to allow light and ventilation. The new C class ward at KTPH is to be replicated in the Jurong General Hospital, due to be ready by 2014. The new C wards prompt the question of just why there is even a need to have C class wards, and why there is a need to differentiate between the B and C classes of subsidised wards. 

The quick answer is contained in the 1993 White Paper on Affordable Health Care. This suggested differentiating hospital wards by “ambience and creature comfort”, with different number of beds per room and different amount of floor space per bed. The idea was to reduce creature comforts in C class wards to curb demand for these highly-subsidised beds, without compromising on medical care. In other words, rationing by discomfort. But now that means testing has been introduced, there is a better way to ration demand for subsidised beds. It is timely to rethink the need for different classes ofsubsidised wards.  

The current system of hospital bed classes is complicated, to say the least. Today, most public hospitals have six ward classes. The three private wards are: A+ with one patient per room and a sitting room attached; A with one or two patients per room; B1 which houses four patients per air-conditioned room. 

There are three subsidised wards: LB2+ which has five people sharing an air-conditioned room and 50 per cent subsidy. LB2 with six people sharing a non air-conditioned room with 50-65 per cent subsidy. LC with eight to 12 people in a dormitory-style ward with no air-conditioning. The ward is open-concept and separated from other wards by a waist-high wall. They are subsidised 65-80 per cent. It looks, and is, confusing. No wonder patients today need financial counselling to understand their choices and likely bills. Hospitals also have to set up a complex administrative procedure to handle the different ward classes.

The system of having multiple subsidized ward classes is likely to become less relevant in future. For one thing, new hospitals in Yishun and Jurong are building C and B2 class wards that resemble private B1 class wards – with ensuite toilets and bathrooms, much more space between beds, and fewer beds per ward. The only physical difference is air-conditioning. The change came about for a very practical – and vital – reason.

There was a major rethink on ward sizes following Sars in 2003, when the severe acute respiratory syndrome bug spread within large hospital wards. Administrators realised the virtues of smaller, self-contained wards to ring-fence or quarantine a disease. It was harder to introduce infection control in open-concept C class wards.  

Today, infection control remains a critical issue. Smaller wards with fewer patients reduce the risk of cross-infection and make it easier to isolate affected patients. This is the key reason wards in new hospitals like the KTPH and the new Jurong General will have fewer patients per ward, even in C class. If having fewer patients share a room and bathroom facilities helps keep hospital-acquired infections to a minimum, then that should be the type of wards built. And if most new subsidised wards built in future will be self-contained rooms with ensuite facilities, there is a need to rethink the old model of having so many subsidised ward classes. Instead, the Ministry of Health can streamline the hospital bed system by doing away with the B2 wards and having just one C class of subsidised ward.  

The strongest argument for this is that the old justification of rationing demand for hospital beds by discomfort is no longer needed, as patients now undergo means testing, and subsidy rates vary according to their income levels. Patients need not fear ending up paying more with a single subsidised class as the rates they pay will be determined by their income levels, not by ward class. So a patient earning $5,000 a month pays more for the same subsidised ward than a patient earning $1,000 a month. 

In fact, the 1993 White Paper acknowledged that rationing by discomfort was not optimal, saying: “The direct way to manage demand, which may eventually become necessary, is to use a means test.” At that time, means testing was an “expensive and administratively clumsy procedure”. But it has become practical with today’s technology and is already in place. 

The next step is obvious: It is no longer necessary to impose levels of discomfort to distinguish wards with various levels of subsidy. Instead, one class of subsidized ward is all that is needed. This would make for easier hospital construction. It is unlikely to add much to the building cost. Standard ward sizes and features make it easier for the nursing staff to carry out their duties. It would also be administratively easier as hospitals will no longer need to explain the different features of a C, B2 or B2+ class ward. Instead, they need only tell patients the level of subsidy they are entitled to. 

To be sure, the change from several to one subsidised class of hospital ward is a major move. It will take years, not least because existing wards will need to be reconfigured. New hospitals can start doing this on a pilot basis. There will be difficulties and confusion during the transition, and patients will need to be re-educated. But the effort will be worth it. Over time, wards will be smaller and self-contained. Subsidised patients will have access to hospital wards within their means that are also great from an infection control point of view.

 Ask the Specialists (1st - 30th Nov)
Gastric Pain, what can I do?
Your Gastric Pain could be a signal of a more serious condition that needs attention; or that you need a change in lifestyle. Ask our Specialist now!
  Your eye and contact lenses
Concerned with the side effects of wearing contact lens? Need a guide on how to take care of your eyes and lenses? Ask our Specialist now!
 Ask the Specialists - Answered Topics
  Aesthetic Eye   Asthma  
  Breast Cancer   Cancer and Nutrition  
  Child's Eye Conditions   Depression  
  Breast Cancer   Eczema  
  Elderly Eye Conditions   Health At Work  
  Heart Disease   LASIK  
  Low Back Pain   Maternal Depression  
  Money and Healthcare   Managing Pain  
  Pre-pregnancy   Prostate Problem  
  Risk of Heart Disease   Sleep  
  Sports Injuries   Thyroid Problems  
  Weight Management        
 Catch up with Health Xchange
  facebook   newsletter